Izzy in Tennessee
Success Stories
If you know of any more success stories to list,
please contact us.
Izzy in Tennessee
October 2011:
Thank you Citizens for Pets in Condos! Information from your website was used to help convince the board of directors here in Knoxville Tennessee that pets are a very beneficial part of the community.
Owners had been the only people allowed to have pets. This particular community has a lot of green space and tends to have many renters. Now renters can have have pets and enjoy the beautiful grounds with their pooches! Thank you again for all of your efforts; they are very appreciated!!!
July 2011, we were informed that attorney David A. Strauss, Fort Lauderdale/Hallandale recently won a case to allow a dog in a "no-pets" condo.
Angel, a service dog
June 2011, I was a victim of no pet in my condo for 13 yrs. My health condition got worse & needed a companion pet. My new management finally told me about National Service Dog Registry online papers to get my dr to sign. Angel is a service dog paper & documents signed by my dr.
Carol's cat
May 2011, rules were changed in a condo complex in Stuart, FL so that at least cats are now allowed. This is definitely a step in the right directions. Carol wrote, "I was able to use the materials and links on your website to put together a handout supporting the amendment of our bylaws to allow one cat per household and to write a memo to the board suggesting implementation of the amendment once it was voted in. The result is that our condo complex now allows one indoor cat per unit. Thank you so much for your site."
April 14, 2011, posted on our petition
I am Living in a condo,after Husband died Had to resort to emotional support enimal,he is my live!!!! and thru Lawers and Hud finaly could have my little well behaved Maltese. Thanks for all the support.
April, 2011, found under windshield of our car (someone saw our bumper sticker):
March, 2011, Linda in Boca Raton wrote:
My dog case was dismissed
I won
Judge was angry at condo Lawer
And I had the worst arbitrator!! [NOTE; In our experience, there has been a lot of bad decisions made by ill-informed DBPR arbitrators.]
March, 2011, The Addison, on the ocean in Boca Raton, changed their documents to allow pets. Currently only pets up to 20 pounds allowed, but they are working on imporving that restriciton. The do have a Pet Committee in place. Way to go!
March, 2011, from Lou S. to Barbara Feeney on our advisory board:
...we FINALLY have everything resolved...a representative from PBC Equal Opportunity Office met with me last Friday. She is drawing up an agreement to include that there will be no further retaliation against us when we return next year. As soon as the board's attorney reviews it and we sign it, it will be over.
Thanks again for all your help and support on this matter and also to Citizens for Pets in Condos for assisting seniors who would truly benefit from a pet.
March, 2011, from Carol S.:
hi and thanks for your help...My Dr. used your info for my second letter to the board. Their response was that for now, since no one is complaining and the dog isn't disturbing anyone and I take her off campus to walk her, I can keep her...for now! just found out they just lost a lawsuit for a dog and it cost them $50,000. thanks again
[NOTE: We pointed her to a sample doctor's letter from the Bazelon Center for Mental Health Law.]
March, 2011, from Lisa P.:
March, 2011, "my condo board filed a suite against me because my enmotional support service dog was walking in a ommon area, the case was dismissed by judge Beller, now they must pay my legal cost which is over $ 20,000 thousand dollars plus. I have lived at the xxxxx xxxxx since 1982,I am a combat wounded veteran from world war 2,my service dog is ROSIE a japanese chin." - Harold C.
February, 2011, Boynton Beach, FL, "I just wanted to thank you for your support and assistance....after much fighting among the board members - their association's attorney told them I was within my legal rights to have my ESA here and they had to approve my request.
"I made a presentation to a small group of owners who participated in a meeting last Tuesday (see attached) and was shocked that I received a resounding round of applause. I guess I had more supporters here than I realized."
(Note: This woman is a "snowbird" who only spends a few months a year in her Florida condo. Her association board origianlly refused her doctor's letter from up north, but she used resources from our web site and consulted with Barbara Feeney on our advisory board, and prevailed in her case.)
January, 2011, Leisureville, a "retirement" 55+ community in Pompano Beach, Florida changed their documents to allow pets.
December, 2010, a nice Xmas present for Ozzie's owner/guardian in Boca Raton: Ozzie has been approved!
Ozzie, all dressed up for the holidays
December, 2010, I'm writing to tell you that I finally got permission to have my dog. There was a great deal of to ing and fro ing in which time the board pulled some really nasty tricks to stall the process. I sent them a DVD of how Jagger helps me and apparently......"THEY LOST IT" so they didn't realize how disabled I was (despite the fact that I also put a link to the video on "Youtube" in all correspondance with their lawyers and the numerous letters from my doctors).
Anyway, I won and would never have heard about my rights had it not been for you. So thanks from me and a big WOOF from Jagger
Best wishes
Mick Walsh
September, 2010, "...a friend's daughter is moving into xxxxx in Pembroke Pines, FL (no pets allowed) and was approved for a service dog. What is so interesting is that the dog is tiny, and the disability of the owner is mental stress without her pet - I feel this is a landmark decision, and many more will follow! It had to be approved by the building's director, and some hassle, it was approved."
August 2010, Elaine wrote us to say "I received a letter from the EEOC and my condominium association has finally conceded and are going to accommodate me. I filed a discrimination charge against them in February and did not back off and see what the universe has done. So anyone out there who is having problems contact me and I will tell you what to do. Now to find a dog."
June 2010, Deena wrote on our Facebook Group page, "Hello to all pet loversa, just letting you all know I won my case to keep my ESD in a no-pet condo, with the help of the information provided on you site, I was able to show the association that It's the law...thank you"
June 2010, Diane in Sunrise wrote:
YOU DID IT AGAIN!!!!!
I COULDN'T HAVE DONE IT WITHOUT YOU!!!!
ON FRIDAY MAY 28, 2010 I GOT A CALL FROM THE BROWARD COUNTY CIVIL RIGHTS DIVISION ADVISING ME THAT MY CONDO ASSOCIATION AND ITS LAWYERS HAD APPROVED MY EMOTIONAL SUPPORT ANIMAL.
AGAIN I COULD NOT HAVE DONE IT WITHOUT THE ORGANIZATION. I FOLLOWED ALL THE STEPS ON YOUR WEB SITE. I REALLY FELT DEFEATED AND VERY DEPRESSED. MY SON GOT IN TOUCH WITH SOMEONE AT CITIZENS FOR PETS IN CONDOS THEY IMMEDIATELY CALLED ME. I TOLD THEM WHAT INFORMATION THAT I HAD SENT TO THE CIVIL RIGHTS DIVISION AND THEY ASSURED ME THAT EVERYTHING WAS OKAY AND THAT I WOULD WIN, AND I WOULD BE ABLE TO KEEP MY WONDERFUL EMOTIONAL SUPPORT ANIMAL. I REALLY DON'T KNOW HOW I CAN EXPLAIN HOW WONDERFUL YOUR ASSOCIATION IS. MOST PEOPLE LIKE ME DON'T HAVE THE MONEY FOR ATTORNEYS AND CITIZENS FOR PETS IN CONDOS HELP YOU SO MUCH. YOU DON'T KNOW HOW MUCH I APPRECIATE ALL THAT YOU HAVE HELPED ME WITH. THANK GOD FOR PEOPLE LIKE YOU.
I AM ANOTHER SUCCESS STORY FOR CITIZENS FOR PETS IN CONDOS. DON'T LET THE CONDO COMMANDOS INTIMIDATE AND HARASS YOU. FIGHT FOR YOUR RIGHTS!!! STAND BY PETS. YOU HAVE RIGHTS TOO.
THANK YOU AGAIN, ...
Rosebud
May, 2010, Fort Lauderdale - Rosebud is allowed as an emotional support animal.
April, 2010, Audra Varkalhoff wrote, "I just wanted to share my success story, that was achieved only with the help of Dear Attorney Marcy I. LaHart and the hard work of my wonderful husband. But we won, my service animal is finally acknowledged by the Condo Board and he will stay there as long as we stay :). The Board dropped the case completely!
Advice for the other owners that battle the same battle; Get an attorney, be aggressive and do not give up. Just remember, that most Boards that even raise the service animal issues, are the ones that are being led by the people who are not well educated, but they feel that they do have a lot of power and they really do not care about your problems or hurt feelings.
One more time, I'd like to thank my Attorney Marcy I. LaHart for an awesome job she did and 100% support of me."
March, 2010, Gus was able to keep his emotional support animal, a 9-pound toy poodle with a doctors letter.
March, 2010 - My husband and I lived in a condo along the NYC riverfront. He was on the Board and was instrumental in passing a Pets' Clause to make our two beloved cats legal! Tuesday, March 9, posted on our petition
February 2010, Marilyn was able to keep her cat, an emotional support animal in her condo, with a properly written doctors letter. "I would have fought tooth and nail to keep my cat, but luckily I only had to fight tooth."
December, 2009, If it were not for Citizens for Pets in Condos my kids (birds), 86 yr old invalid mother, 19 (elderly and handicapped) neighbors and their kids (birds and cats) would be homeless today or would have had to give up the pets we have loved for so many years. They were and continue to be a wealth of information and support. We all received 10 day notices at the time when the housing market was at it's lowest. Many of them are on fixed incomes with no where else to go and giving up our pets was not an option. Nor was leaving our homes of 15-31 years. All because of one Nazi board of directors. Everyone here lived openly with birds on their patios for the 31 years I have lived here and now it is 32 thanks to this organnizations! They are truly a Godsend! (reported on http://www.causes.com/causes/279038-citizens-for-pets-in-condos-inc).
November, 2009, Stephanie posted on our Facebook Group
I won! I am allowed to have my emotional service animal. I won against the condo commandos. How? I put the cart before the horse and didn't do it the right way with initiating a request for accomodations, but I filed discrimination with HUD, ADA, and lastly the Palm Beach County EEOC. The later won this for me. My c...ase manager was partial because she had no choice but she got me a fantastic legal aid attorney who was there for me every step of the way and fought this battle to keep my dog when they were telling me that I wouldn't have a roof over my head or have to get rid of my dog. Today I won, I can keep my dog, I can move into my new unit. There are stipulations I can live with but I can tell you that there is a way to win this and there are those who are willing to fight the HOA for you.
October 2009, HUD helped a man in Palm Beach county keep his standard poodle, his emotional support animal." The homeowners association only permits 1 dog under 20 lbs. I had a letter from my doctor establishing that my dog was an emotional companion animal. The lawyers for homeowners association put up roadblocks for the better part of 7 months."
October 2009, a man in Plantation (name withheld to protect confidentiality) won a 6-year case brought against him by his condo association. Carol Franco, his mental health therapist, did a four hour deposition for his defense. She says' "I'm so glad his rights were upheld. It should never have been a case to begin with."
 |
 |
| Jasper | Elsa |
Marilyn with Luke
"On Feb. 20, 2009 after 6 months a wonderful attorney (Marcy I. LaHart) information from David and Maida, I have a success story to be told. In short I relocated here in July from Atlanta with my Service Dog Luke to take care of my 97 year old Aunt, our condo is in a 'No Dog' condo in Royal Palm Beach. During these 6 months my Aunt had a stroke, I just stayed low key, my attorney finally got the approval today, under 2 conditions that I pick-up Luke's pooh and Luke has his shots. Without Marcy LaHart we wouldn't have gotten this approval.
"We wish everyone a 'Happy Day of Approval,' Marilyn & Luke"
January 2009, My condo, Rapallo, is now a Pet Friendly building. It took us 5 years, but we are there now. It was a matter of rescinding the no-pet rule in the by-laws and a lot of phone calls, letters and speakers. I used many of your quotes, so I am still at it. I now have 2 cats. One is a rescue and sooo dear. Bobby
October, 2008, from Harold: "the broward county human rights board ruled that I am disabled person, my dog is a service animal and I have a right to full enjoyment of the condominiumm property-my prescription states that my dog is for emotional support and seizures"
Loretta's dog Herman
June 2008 from Loretta: "Our family doctor gave us a note for my husband’s disability, and it is in compliance with the rules of the ADA ,which therefore no one can say anything, unless they want to go up against the ADA ,the condo lawyers say that they can’t fight it since it is a disability note from our Dr. We just have to get a note once a year saying his disability has not changed/or mine.
June, 2008, from Marianne: We have great news. One year after trying to get Eddie our long haired mini dachshund in to our condo "legally" he is in. We had been sneaking him in the building past the front door security in a bag and walking him a few streets away for over a year.
The board decided to write a letter to "grandfather" in any pets smaller than 20lbs. We had to do the normal office registration. It was a great feeling to finally present him at the front door on my shoulder. Turns out that all of the security guards are dog lovers and everyone says hello to Eddie now as we go for our walks.
[Our comment back: Congratulations, but this is mixed news. From all the letters we get, I anticipate how upset you will be years later when Eddie passes on and you won’t be able to replace him. The Friars in Ft. Lauderdale do grief counseling and count the grief over losing a pet as one of their major issues.]
Joy snuggling with Bullwinkle
See videos of Joy and one of her birds: Kissy Bird and More Kisses
May, 2008, from Joy in Tamarac:
After 3 of us showed up with our letters from a physician stating our pets were medically necessary The board has decided to not enforce the “no pet rule”. At least for now. I feel it is only a temporary reprieve.The worst of the board members resigned and the other two are snow birds.”
May, 2008: Board Allows Animal for Medical Condition (Lakeland, FL)
April, 2008:
February, 2008: Judith did not just accept the board's pronouncement that Chloe (seen above) was not allowed. She went to the court and looked up the documents that were filed. The official legal documents said that a dog is allowed if medically necessary, which it was. They had to accept her doctor's note.
August , 2007: Because of the assistance of the Attorney General's Office of Civil Rights, cat Max can stay in the condo. Here is the earlier story when we first learned about Ethyl and her service cat: Woman Calls Cat Lifeline. Click here to read the letter from the AG's office.
July, 2007: With the assistance of a TV news team
advocate, a 69-year-old woman in Port Charlotte, FL won the right to keep her
17-year-old cat Samba in her condo. Her cat is an emotional support animal for
a condition covered by disability laws. Click
here to read more.
February, 2007: " It has been passed by our Board of Directors to officially allow support/therapy animals in our condo.
We have passed and implemented a strict animal policy. We have set up a therapy/support animal committee to monitor the animals and to make sure owners abide by our rules. It has taken over a year to get this passed and up and running but after all the hard work, it is worth and my mother now has a wonderful chihuahua that has changed her life! Oh by the way I had to get on the board to get this done!
Kindest regards and keep up the good fight."
Marilyn, Aventura, FL
February, 2007: Remember this story?:
December, 2006: Condo board backs down and allows two cats
November, 2006: State backs therapy dog's owner.
June, 2006: Cat Owner Victory Puts Condo Board in Doghouse
|
|
|
|
|
pictures of some more success stories |
||
April, 2005: Deerfield dog owner trumps ‘no-pet’ rule with medical necessity -- Meadows of Crystal Lake HOA (original article http://www.ccfj.net/HOAFLpet.html)
February, 2005: Disabled Woman's Dog Has Its Day
around 2004: "When i was having trouble keeping my dogs i contacted hud and they helped me. Thank God i was able to keep my pets. The condo isn't allowed to harrass me....Also my Dr helped me a lot the office manager that works for loves animals and she has one.We could never live without our dog we are petparents no kids. And no car to go to the vet." - Iris & William Grape, Sunrise, FL.
February, 2003: Florida State Statute 760.23 was applied in this case to prevent eviction of a disabled person with a "support animal."
2002, Ft Lauderdale: My Moms condo tried to evict her because she needed ever so deparately to have an adorable puppy for emotional support after my Dad passed away. Well I hired an amazing lawyer and we not only won – but the condo had to pay the legal fees.
Bubbele was Allowed to Stay
About 10 years ago, Barry Silver, an attorney in Boca Raton represented an elderly gentleman who lives in Boca Chase who owned a dog named Bubbele. The Association told him and his wife their dog had to leave, but after a doctor's note indicating the dog was therapeutic for the husband's cancer condition, some negotiations, some adverse publicity for the Association, and the threat of a lawsuit the Association relented and Bubbele was allowed to stay.
Wanton Weighed In
In another case, Attorney Silver represented the owner of a dog named Wanton. The board said the dog weighed too much and thus was "caninus non grata." He showed that the rules which prohibited dogs were passed improperly and thus, invalid, and Wanton was allowed to stay.
Barry Silver had some recent success fighting other condo abuses, read here.
The officers of Citizens for Pets in Condos have had mixed success:
Spike and Priya
Maida Genser (President and Treasurer of Citizens for Pets in Condos) won the right to keep her two cats , Spike and Priya, with a THIRD doctor's letter attesting to the need for emotional support animals. They were rescues from a pound in Michigan. How can you save animals and then, in the regrettable wording used in the condo documents, "dispose of" them. She helped two other unit owners in her condo complex keep their pets by educating the condo board and their "Fining Committee" on laws regarding emotional support pets. (Of course, the board "rewarded" her by unceremoniously removing her from the Finance Committee.) read more
|
|
|
When David Shapiro (VP of Citizens for Pets in Condos) was snow bird, living part of the year in New York and part down here, he boarded his dog up in New York. When he moved down to Florida full time, he wanted his dog with him. He spent a lot of money on lawyers' fees to prove there were inconsistencies in his condo complexes. He won the right to keep his dog Lexi, but was given the usual "poison pill." He was told he could not replace Lexi with another dog. When Lexi had to be put down, it was doubly devastating for David. He did get another dog, and predictably was challenged by his condo board. David spent thousands more to get his dog trained as a service dog, money that was not usefully spent because before Lexie II had papers and a service wrap, she could do everything she does not, just from natural doggie instinct.
